Elements of a Crime: Breaking Down the Offense
Key Takeaways:
- Every crime consists of two main parts, the “Actus Reus” and the “Mens Rea.” The prosecution must prove both parts for your action to be legally considered a crime.
- Actus Reus is Latin for “guilty act” and refers to the physical activity or behavior that breaks the law.
- Mens Rea is Latin for “guilty mind.”
Have you ever wondered what makes an act a criminal offense? In some cases, people will do seemingly similar things and one will be arrested while the other will not be charged with a crime. Being suspected or guilty of a crime is not just about doing something wrong or allegedly wrong.
Law enforcement looks at specific parts, or “elements,” of an act to determine if it is a crime. These elements must be present for whatever crime you are accused of. To convict you, the criminal justice system must establish that all the elements of a crime have been met to prove your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
If you or someone you know is facing criminal charges, consult with an experienced criminal defense attorney.
What Are the Basic Elements of a Crime?
Generally, the commission of a crime involves two main things: the action itself and the thought behind it. These are known as the “actus reus” (the action) and the “mens rea” (the mindset). Both the actus reas and mens rea must be present for an action to rise to the level of a crime.
The prosecution must prove both parts for your action to be legally considered a crime.
What Are the Different Types of Mens Rea?
There are varying degrees of mens rea that can ultimately determine your guilt. They can vary based on your state of mind and intent. Here are a few types:
- Intentional: You do something purposefully, fully aware of your actions. It is important to note that some crimes are called “specific intent” crimes, for example, “Attempted murder.”
- Reckless: You know that your actions are risky, but you do them anyway.
- Negligent: You are not careful, ignore safety guidelines, or are just not as careful as a reasonable person should be, which ends up causing someone harm or breaking the law.
What Are the Different Types of Actus Reus?
Just like mens rea, actus reus can also have different classifications different based on the action. Here are some types:
- Voluntary actions: These are actions you do on your own, like hitting someone.
- Omission of an act: Sometimes, not doing something for which you have a legal duty can be a crime, like not feeding your pet.
- Possession: Having something illegal, like certain drugs, can also be an actus reus.
What Is Concurrence?
Concurrence is when the actus reus and mens rea happen at the same time. For a crime to occur, there must be a concurrence between your action and intention. If you plan to steal something (mens rea) but never actually do it (actus reus), there’s no concurrence.
What Is Causation?
Causation is about linking your action directly to the outcome. Simply put, your action must have directly caused the harm or the illegal result. If you set a trap that hurts someone hours later, the causation links your action to the injury.
What are Some Examples of Elements of a Crime?
Example 1: Theft
- Actus reus: Taking someone’s phone without permission.
- Mens rea: Intending to keep the phone permanently.
- Concurrence: The intention to steal coincides with taking the phone.
- Causation: The owner loses their phone because you took it.
Example 2: Drunk Driving
- Actus reus: Driving a car while under the influence of alcohol.
- Mens rea: Knowing you’re drunk but deciding to drive anyway.
- Concurrence: You’re driving while knowingly intoxicated.
- Causation: Any harm caused is directly linked to you driving drunk.
Example 3: Trespassing
- Actus reus: An unlawful intrusion or invasion on a property.
- Mens rea: To which you have no ownership or right to enter.
- Concurrence: With the intent to intrude.
- Causation: Causing damages.
What are Some Defenses to the Elements of a Crime?
Sometimes, you might have valid reasons or defenses for what happened. Here are a few:
- Mistake: You genuinely didn’t know what you were doing was wrong. This can make the mens rea necessary for the crime difficult to prove. A defendant’s actions or conduct is often more provable than a defendant’s intent.
- Duress: You were forced or threatened to commit the crime.
- Self-Defense: You committed the act to protect yourself or others.
- Insanity: You were not in the right mental state to understand your actions.
Remember, proving these defenses can be complex, and each case is unique.
Understanding How It All Works
Understanding the elements of a crime can help you see how the law works, what the prosecutor needs to prove you guilty, and the possible defenses you may have. While you may have committed an unlawful act or criminal act, you can avoid criminal liability if the criminal prosecution cannot prove the elements of the crime.
If you have been accused of a crime, contact an experienced criminal defense attorney. Experts in criminal law; an attorney will assess your case, find any weaknesses in the prosecution’s case, and assert your best defenses.
At LawInfo, we know legal issues can be stressful and confusing. We are committed to providing you with reliable legal information in a way that is easy to understand. Our pages are written by legal writers and reviewed by legal experts. We strive to present information in a neutral and unbiased way, so that you can make informed decisions based on your legal circumstances.