When Does Discipline Become Abuse?
In this article
- Is Spanking Your Child Legal?
- Can a Parent Be Arrested for Hitting or Disciplining a Child?
- Is It Illegal If You Leave Marks or Bruises on a Child After Discipline?
- Is Slapping a Child Considered Abuse?
- Is It Legal to Discipline Your Child With a Belt or Other Object?
- Is Corporal Punishment Legal?
- Is It Parental Discipline or Child Abuse?
Some types of physical actions are clearly abusive. It is never okay for an adult to sexually abuse a child, provide a child with illegal drugs or to burn or choke a child. However, the line between parenting and child abuse is not always that clear.
Many families strongly believe in spanking as a means of punishment, for example. Other families believe that spanking is a form of child abuse. Most states do not have a law that prohibits spanking but instead rely on their child abuse statutes to determine if an individual case crossed the line between discipline and abuse.
Most states do not prohibit parents from spanking their children. However, all states have statutes that define child abuse. If a parent is accused of child abuse because he or she has struck a child then a judge or jury would need to decide whether the parent’s actions constituted abuse, based on the state law as applied to the facts of the specific case.
The answer really depends on whether the action can be categorized as abuse or not. There are federal and state laws that define child abuse and if a parent’s actions meet the definition of child abuse, then it is possible that criminal charges may result.
The Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA) is set of federal laws that create legal minimum standards each state must follow in their own child abuse laws. States can add to these standards, but can’t have fewer protections than this baseline.
The act essentially requires each state to recognize abuse and neglect as not only acts by caretakers, but failures to act as well, when it results in an array of consequences from death to physical or emotional harm. Any act or failure to act that can present an impending risk of serious harm could be found to be child abuse, in addition to any state laws addressing child abuse.
If the marks or bruises cause lasting damage to the child, then the likelihood of criminal charges may be greater. The degree of the discipline may cross the line of child abuse under federal or state law. The individual circumstances of each case are evaluated by law enforcement and the prosecuting authority with regard to whether criminal charges are pursued. Certainly, if the discipline reaches a level of lasting physical and psychological harm, that is, by most definitions, child abuse.
In many states that strictly follow the CAPTA rules alone, quick acts of physical discipline that don’t leave lasting damage or other types of serious harm won’t meet the definition of child abuse. A quick slap or a spanking, for example, is generally allowed by law.
Prolonged physical force, or intense force that uses full adult strength, which could include a belt or another object, or even a closed fist against a child could be more likely to cross the line between discipline and abuse. If a child is injured by the force or it leaves other lasting effects, it might be considered an abusive punishment.
Corporal punishment is the intentional infliction of pain that is designed to punish a person for his or her actions and teach that person not to do it again. In the United States, corporal punishment most often refers to the physical discipline of children in a school setting. About half of all states, including California and Massachusetts, have outlawed corporal punishment.
However, in many states corporal punishment remains legal. Corporal punishment seems to be most prevalent in southern states such as Florida and Mississippi. In these states, corporal punishment, like parental physical discipline, is allowed, but the right to inflict corporal punishment is not unlimited. School administrators, teachers and other adults must still abide by the state’s child abuse laws.
Physical discipline of children is a hotly contested topic in the United States. Some parents believe it to be an effective means of disciplining their children and other parents believe it to be cruel. The law does not prevent all physical discipline of children, but it does provide limits and it seeks to protect children from child abuse.
Were You Arrested?
Experienced criminal defense lawyers in our directory will protect your rights and defend your freedom.